Should you get Twitter Blue? That depends on whether you consider yourself a “power user.” The platform’s new subscription service, which costs $3 per month, comes with a suite of requested features: bookmark folders for organizing saved tweets, a “reading mode” that declutters long threads, and a (sort of) edit button, good for 30 seconds of revisions after a tweet is sent. It also comes with ad-free access to articles from a number of journalism outfits, like The Washington Post, Rolling Stone, and The Atlantic.
Compared to the number of third-party apps that give Twitter more brawn—plug-ins that help you auto-delete your tweets or search within the tweets you’ve liked—Twitter Blue feels a little overwhelming. But considering it’s the company’s first-ever paid product, Twitter has chosen to go narrow, catering to a small group of people by giving them exactly the features they want.
Twitter Blue doesn’t get rid of ads in a user’s feed or change much about the tweeting experience itself. But it is part of the company’s plan to diversify its revenue beyond advertising and become more than a place to share thoughts in 280 characters. In January, Twitter acquired the newsletter company Revue and Breaker, an audio social service, to build up new product offerings around newsletter subscription and audio chat. In March, it acquired Scroll, an ad-free news reader.
People who liked Scroll will find a lot to love about Twitter Blue. It’s almost exactly the same service, but less costly: Scroll charged $5 per month. Part of the Twitter Blue subscription fees will go directly back to the publishers it partners with. Twitter did not disclose how much but wrote in a blog post that “our goal is to help each publishing partner make 50 percent more per person than they would’ve made from serving ads to that person.”
Twitter seems to be defining its “power users” as people who consume a lot of news or primarily use the platform for sharing and reading articles. For those people, Twitter Blue certainly is a nicer reading experience. It’s convenient to browse the day’s top articles and then click into them without ads, which also makes them load faster. And Twitter threads look fantastic in “reading mode,” a design that emphasizes the text rather than the replies. On the other hand, “reading mode” makes it harder to see the full scope of a conversation, which used to be the whole point of Twitter.
In that sense, Twitter Blue has arrived at an awkward time as the company searches to find its real value add. Is it a place for creators? A place to read the news? A place where you can have a conversation with anyone, from your coworker to the Dalai Lama? Some of Twitter Blue’s features, like the ability to choose between a few color palettes and icons, used to be a standard part of the service. Customizable wallpaper was available to every user, for free, until 2015. That history has also made users confused about why they’re supposed to be paying extra now. “I’m trying out twitter blue and it’s everything people have been asking for but now you have to pay for it 🙄🙄🙄🙄,” one person tweeted.
If one group of users is happy, it’s journalists, who—based on my own network, at least—are subscribing in droves. But as the company considers other premium features, it will do well to look beyond its role as a platform just for news.